Bug? I built Citizens Defense Force, but Base can Scrap Perimeter Defense

[Lord Avalon]

I built Morgan Energy Monopoly on the SE coast of my starting continent. Later I saw "*Perimeter Defense" in my facilities list, like it had built one - except that I had already built the Citizens Defense Force, and this base did not actually build a Perimeter Defense, so it shouldn't be able to scrap it.

Since I didn't notice this right away, I don't know if these saves are any good (I had to go back 20 and 30 turns).

[Nexii]

Might be the free perimeter defense on capture of hive base bug?  I think I've seen this recurring although Yitzi had fixed this in a previous patch.  can't confirm though yet

[Yitzi]

Essentially, that star means the game thinks you did build one.  Most likely it is (as Nexii said) due to the "free PD on capture of hive base" bug, which I have not managed to fix.  And a savegame that doesn't let me reproduce the bug isn't going to be very helpful.

[Lord Avalon]

So when I captured a Hive base, one of my bases got a Perimeter Defense?

[Geo]

So when I captured a Hive base, one of my bases got a Perimeter Defense?

That's the bug.

[Lord Avalon]

Essentially, that star means the game thinks you did build one.  Most likely it is (as Nexii said) due to the "free PD on capture of hive base" bug, which I have not managed to fix.  And a savegame that doesn't let me reproduce the bug isn't going to be very helpful.

Sorry. Here's a save where I'm about to take People's Endeavor and wipe out Yang - and another save where I sabotaged the PD first. I noticed that getting a free PD doesn't always happen.


Is it related to having the Citizen's Defense Force?

[Yitzi]

Essentially, that star means the game thinks you did build one.  Most likely it is (as Nexii said) due to the "free PD on capture of hive base" bug, which I have not managed to fix.  And a savegame that doesn't let me reproduce the bug isn't going to be very helpful.

Sorry. Here's a save where I'm about to take People's Endeavor and wipe out Yang - and another save where I sabotaged the PD first. I noticed that getting a free PD doesn't always happen.


Is it related to having the Citizen's Defense Force?

Shouldn't be related to the CDF.  Let me check out the save...

[Yitzi]

Well, that save provided enough information to find the procedure responsible.  Now I have to figure out what's actually going on...

[Yitzi]

Ok, I found the bug and know how to fix it...or would, except that there are two possibilities of what's supposed to happen.  I'll post a poll regarding which it should be.

EDIT: I examined a bit more and have reached a conclusion: What's supposed to happen is that the conquered base loses the perimeter defense, and there are actually four bugs, two due to a poor copy-paste, the third (and most important) probably due to a confusion of variables, and the fourth a simple oversight that isn't relevant without modding (but once the others are fixed, could cause a sea base to lack a pressure dome under the wrong conditions).  I'm in the middle of patch 3.1 so I can't post a fix now, but it'll be included in 3.1.