Alpha Centauri Forums
  The Game
  Poll : what do you think of SMAC?

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | prefs | faq | search

Author Topic:   Poll : what do you think of SMAC?
SMAniaC posted 08-04-99 07:22 PM ET   Click Here to See the Profile for SMAniaC   Click Here to Email SMAniaC  
I adore the game : 0
I like the game : 0
I don't like the game : 1
I hate the game : 0
Krushala posted 08-04-99 08:02 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Krushala  Click Here to Email Krushala     
I adore the game : 0
I like the game : 1
I don't like the game : 1
I hate the game : 0
Shining1 posted 08-04-99 08:17 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Shining1  Click Here to Email Shining1     
I adore the game : 0
I like the game : 1
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0
Vinny posted 08-04-99 08:48 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Vinny  Click Here to Email Vinny     
I adore the game : 0
I like the game : 2
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0
Jeffrey Morris FIRAXIS posted 08-04-99 08:50 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Jeffrey Morris FIRAXIS  Click Here to Email Jeffrey Morris FIRAXIS     
I adore the game : 1
I like the game : 2
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0

jkm

firaxis games

MajiK6pt5 posted 08-04-99 10:33 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for MajiK6pt5  Click Here to Email MajiK6pt5     

I adore the game : 2
I like the game : 2
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0
bomberman posted 08-04-99 11:47 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for bomberman  Click Here to Email bomberman     
I adore the game : 2
I like the game : 3
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0
TurkeyTom posted 08-05-99 01:04 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for TurkeyTom    
I adore the game : 2
I like the game : 4
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0


TurkeyTom, happily lurking.

Alexnm posted 08-05-99 01:29 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Alexnm  Click Here to Email Alexnm     
I adore the game: 3
I like the game: 4
I don't like the game: 2
I hate the game: 0

Walk with Planet...
Alexnm

Nemesis posted 08-05-99 05:31 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Nemesis  Click Here to Email Nemesis     
I've been reading this forum for a few months now.
It's quit nice to be able to learn about all your tips,
tricks and ideas.
Reading this thread I see that some people don't like
the game and have been posting here for months?
Maybe JMK's not so wise remark did have some truth
in it afterall? I mean, what's the use to post here
when you realy don't like SMAC. Move on, buy another game
and get on with your life.

I adore the game: 4
I like the game: 4
I don't like the game: 2
I hate the game: 0

Darstar, I think your a wise and honourable man.
Please call of your vendetta on my friends.

Freddz posted 08-05-99 06:00 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Freddz  Click Here to Email Freddz     
I adore the game: 4
I like the game: 4
I don't like the game: 2
I hate the game: 0
I hate Firaxis: 1

Hehe...

Resource Consumer posted 08-05-99 06:08 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Resource Consumer  Click Here to Email Resource Consumer     
FRAUD

ELECTORAL MALPRACTICE

Firaxis can't vote for themselves.

Furore posted 08-05-99 06:39 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Furore  Click Here to Email Furore     
I adore the game: 4 (excl. bias), 5 (incl. bias)
I like the game: 4
I don't like the game: 2
I hate the game: 0
I hate Firaxis: 1


SMAniaC posted 08-05-99 09:16 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SMAniaC  Click Here to Email SMAniaC     
Nemesis,

I like the game for what it could have been, and I also like the story, seven factions, mindworms and so on, but it could have been made much better.
This is a better representation of what I think of SMAC.

I adore the game atmosphere.
I don't like the gameplay.
I hate Firaxis.

SMACTrek posted 08-05-99 09:33 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SMACTrek  Click Here to Email SMACTrek     
I like SMAC.

I liked the demo enough to buy the game. I'm probably going to get SMACX. The various bugs have dampened my enthusiasm a bit. But what I've seen in SMAC tells me that Firaxis will be the undisputed kings as releases get better.

In the meantime, I'm also going to check out Test of Time, since I'm so new to TBS that I don't have any version of Civ 2.

Okay.. I'm out of the closet now. I'm a S***ophant.

SMACTrek posted 08-05-99 09:34 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SMACTrek  Click Here to Email SMACTrek     
And now I hate myself
akathisia posted 08-05-99 09:45 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for akathisia  Click Here to Email akathisia     
Adore 5 (6 if you're biased)
Like 4
Don't Like 2
Hate 0
Hate Firaxis 1
Hate SMACTrek 1 (by SMACTrek)
MikeH II posted 08-05-99 11:14 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for MikeH II  Click Here to Email MikeH II     
Adore++

Which I think gives:

Adore 6 (7 if you're biased)
Like 4
Don't Like 2
Hate 0

R A Spottiswood posted 08-05-99 11:31 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for R A Spottiswood  Click Here to Email R A Spottiswood     
Adore 8
Like 4
Don't Like 2
Hate 0
Beginning to regret returning to the Forum: 1
SBP posted 08-05-99 03:41 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SBP  Click Here to Email SBP     
Adore 9
Like 5
Dont like 2
Hate 0

SBP posted 08-05-99 03:46 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SBP  Click Here to Email SBP     
Whoops!

Adore 9
Like 4
Dont like 2
Hate 0

dilbert posted 08-05-99 04:57 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for dilbert    
adore 10
like 4
don't like 2
hate 0
AnnC posted 08-05-99 06:15 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for AnnC    
Great concept, sloppy implementation - that makes it a "like".

adore 10
like 5
don't like 2
hate 0

Inix posted 08-05-99 06:26 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Inix  Click Here to Email Inix     
I guage a games worth by how many hours of fun i have had playing the game. so SMAC gets an "adore" rating.

BTW RC, i dont c why an employee's vote counts less, if he plays it and has fun doing so i dont c why is job should disqualify or degrade the value of his opinion. Assuming u were not joking, wich u probably were now that i think about it...

anyway the tally now is

Adore: 11
Like: 5
Dont like:2
Hate:0

Q Cubed posted 08-05-99 07:06 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Q Cubed  Click Here to Email Q Cubed     
Adore: 12
Like: 4
Dislike: 2
Hate: 0
Regrets returning to the forum: 2
Wants the good ol' days to return: 1
Khan Singh posted 08-05-99 07:09 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Khan Singh  Click Here to Email Khan Singh     
SMAC, Je t'adore : 13
4
2
0
Colon posted 08-05-99 08:18 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Colon  Click Here to Email Colon     
It could have been adore....

I adore the game : 13
I like the game : 5
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0

Zardoz posted 08-05-99 08:32 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Zardoz    
I adore the game : 14
I like the game : 5
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0
SMACTrek posted 08-05-99 08:43 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SMACTrek  Click Here to Email SMACTrek     
Inix, it's technically a conflict of interest. Of course, not much is at stake so it's nothing to get truly upset over.
tfs99 posted 08-05-99 08:50 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for tfs99  Click Here to Email tfs99     
Like. Could have been adore.

I adore the game : 14
I like the game : 6
I don't like the game : 2
I hate the game : 0

SMAX n ... Ted S.

Zoetrope posted 08-06-99 08:06 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Zoetrope  Click Here to Email Zoetrope     
1253 posts? Cockeysville? Mr Morris, did you invent both of those?

Since adoration is by Magi, and I don't claim to be Sid, chalk up one more "Like".

But please, Firaxis, make the F4 base window and unit slides maintain their position! (Until the user tells them to move.)

Adore: 14
Like : 7
Dislike: 2
Hate: 0



Giant posted 08-06-99 09:49 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Giant    
Adore: 14.5
Like : 7.5
Dislike: 2
Hate: 0

It's right in the middle so I'll go 50-50 .
Giant

Transcendent posted 08-06-99 10:07 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Transcendent    
Been playing for a frightening no. hours on SMAC since feb. and still going strong. No signs of letting up either. Could say that SMAC is somewhat addictive so another point for adore.

Adore: 15.5
Like : 7.5
Dislike: 2
Hate: 0

By the way, I agree with Nemesis about the pricks who voted 'dislike'. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but the fact is these 2 have been posting on the forums for months & months and obviously play the game all the time. Can't be that bad then can it?
Stick to Pac Man or Donkey Kong in that case - probably more your style.

Transcendent
Fed up with the hypocracy of people who always moan about the shortcomings of SMAC yet still play it.

Johnny V posted 08-06-99 10:07 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Johnny V    
I adore the game. I don't play multiplayer so that might be why I haven't hit some of the problems.
icosahedron posted 08-06-99 01:18 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for icosahedron    
Adore is too strong a word. I adore my wife, I don't adore a game. Like is too weak a word, as I greatly enjoy the game. So 1/2 pt. to each.

Adore: 16
Like : 8
Dislike: 2
Hate: 0

And I am fed up with people who want to repress the opinions of others just because they differ. C'mon, get over yourself! Unless I am your boss/wife/kid/friend, or unless you are a shareholder in the company which owns the rights to SMAC, why do you care what I or anyone else thinks or says about the game?

I mean, most people like ice cream, but some don't. That is their prerogative. Damn conformist nuts! You're going to get us all killed, or at least stuck in a boring, repressive society.

- icosahedron
(Also tired of people who use ten-dollar words and can't seem to spell them right -- friggin' hypocrites!)

SMAniaC posted 08-06-99 01:35 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SMAniaC  Click Here to Email SMAniaC     
"Stick to Pac Man or Donkey Kong in that case - probably more your style."
Transcendent, don't begin to insult people for voting dislike.

I am only posting on this forum for three weeks, not months and months and I don't play it all the time.

I don't moan about SMAC, I actually try to avoid further mistakes of Firaxis. I am putting a lot of time in Civ3, hoping that they won't ruin another game.

RSHER posted 08-06-99 04:23 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for RSHER  Click Here to Email RSHER     
I have to vote adore, sometimes even my family takes second place.

Adore: 17
Like : 8
Dislike: 2
Hate: 0

JohnIII posted 08-06-99 04:32 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for JohnIII  Click Here to Email JohnIII     
"obviously play the game all the time."
I don't. It's not even on my HD. And yes, I have posted here for months (3? 4?) Instead I am currently absorbed in International Cricket Captain 2, so don't call me a dumb shoot-em-up fan, OK?
Adore: 17
Like: 8
Dislike: 3
Hate: 0

John III

CEO Landon posted 08-06-99 05:09 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for CEO Landon  Click Here to Email CEO Landon     
Pretty simple poll. I would have to say adore. Looks like a landslide so far. Sorry, SMAniaC!

Adore: 18
Like: 8
Dislike: 3
Hate: 0

CEO Landon (a lurking veteran)

Freddz posted 08-06-99 06:17 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Freddz  Click Here to Email Freddz     
Okay, seriously, while I think the game is good, I thought Civ2 was good and Civ1 was great. All good games right? But theyre so darn alike and SMAC introduces so little that improves the game. So, I would have to respond "I dont like the game".

Adore: 18
Like: 8
Dislike: 4
Hate: 0

Resource Consumer posted 08-06-99 06:20 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Resource Consumer  Click Here to Email Resource Consumer     
Inix,

You are entitled to your point of view as a human being. You are even entitled to change it when confronted with suitable evidence.

In return, we are entitled to you making the effort that your posts can be legibly interepreted by speakers of some standard of international english. I, amongst many don't like cing people sk8 and this sort of crap.

It's not funny and it's not smart. You demean yourself by this.

To the point in question. Mr Morris does indeed have an inalienable right as a human being to express his love for a game - however buggy and ****ed up it may be.

However, where I worry, is that there are so many brownnosers who sniff the **** of a FIRAXIS tag and will jump just as he says.

OK, I exaggerate. But to do so in a public forum, I think this is just another example of ill-advised public pronouncement.

Alternatively, given that this forum is dying then it may have been a clever ploy to ramp things on a slow gradient pre-SMACX. The recent resurrection of Brian Reynolds merely confirms my suspicion.

MechaDestroyer posted 08-06-99 07:20 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for MechaDestroyer  Click Here to Email MechaDestroyer     
As icosahedron said, I really like the game, but to that point. Half.

Adore: 18.5
Like: 8.5
Dislike: 4
Hate: 0

MechaDestroyer
"The True Destroyer"

HolyWarrior posted 08-07-99 11:46 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for HolyWarrior  Click Here to Email HolyWarrior     
If you had asked me a couple months ago, I would've said adore, but now it's just like.

18.5-9.5-4-0.

OldWarrior_42 posted 08-08-99 02:24 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for OldWarrior_42  Click Here to Email OldWarrior_42     
I like the game so it is one more for like. I dont like flamers or people who have no tolerance for other people's opinions that may differ from theirs. I also am not too crazy about how Firaxis handles the internet community. It seems to me almost like it is a chore for them. Hopefully things will change but if not ...oh well. I will still play the game though. That I cant help as I am a game junkie. I gave up smokin pot 10 years ago, drinking alcohol 9 years ago and now cigarettes 2 months ago. I will not give up my games ...or my coffee.
SMAniaC posted 08-08-99 12:31 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SMAniaC  Click Here to Email SMAniaC     
Posts are beginning to stagnate on this topic.
Has this forum only 40 visitors?

HAHAHAHA

SMAniaC
Supporting ACOL

Thread ClosedTo close this thread, click here (moderator or admin only).

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Alpha Centauri Home

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.18
© Madrona Park, Inc., 1998.