Alpha Centauri Forums
  Old Test Forums
  UoP internal conflicts

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | prefs | faq | search

Author Topic:   UoP internal conflicts
Andrew Kasantsev posted 11-10-98 08:30 PM ET   Click Here to See the Profile for Andrew Kasantsev   Click Here to Email Andrew Kasantsev  
In some FAQ (or interview?) there was description of UoP faction, and low level of morale and unity was mentioned as factional trait. I can understand that - scientists are selfish lot, they egoists and dont like to work under other guidance very much.
But in story there are NO conflicts between Saratov's people! They really worship him, it seems! Where are his opponents? I think that there had to be at least ONE good opponent in story.
DHE_X2 posted 11-10-98 08:41 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for DHE_X2  Click Here to Email DHE_X2     
Right now, they are still cooperating and are part of the same crew. Im sure some internal conflicts will arise.
Octopus posted 11-10-98 10:41 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Octopus  Click Here to Email Octopus     
I think that it is because there is a difference between who is currently a subordinate of Saratov and what the UoP faction is all about. Currently, Saratov is bossing around engineers and technicians, who are generally pretty good about working in teams on problems. Once the faction is set up with its devotion to science (rather than problem solving, which is what engineers like, in my opinion) the ego problems you mention will come out.

The interesting thing about Saratov is that he does seem to be a good technical manager. He has an excellent grasp on the capabilities of his subordinates, he can make good technical decisions in a crisis, and he recognizes the importance of supporting his people (e.g. they need guns when there's a band of maniacs running around on the ship). But, he then puts all that aside and sets up a "science" faction. It's a bit puzzling to me. Is this scientist/engineer dichotomy non-existant in Russia, so Saratov doesn't know better? (Or, more likely, Firaxis has used Star Trek as the model for engineers...).

Andrew Kasantsev posted 11-10-98 11:19 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Andrew Kasantsev  Click Here to Email Andrew Kasantsev     
Such dichotomy never was a great problem in Russia, as far as I know. We had a LARGE amount of engineer/organisator - from Kurchatov to Korolev (nuclear bomb and space program) - they was great scientists and good organizators. Saratov is unconvincable in his unemotionality - russian had a great humor sense - we had to, it is neccesary to survive here ...
outlyr242 the rebirth posted 11-11-98 12:47 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for outlyr242 the rebirth  Click Here to Email outlyr242 the rebirth     
I work with a woman who ditched the USSR. She said to keep their sanity, she and her friends would just sit around and complain about how stupid the govt was.

Also, like in civ2 i don't see the riot factor commint into effect until the cities get rather large, eg. until the population grows beyond the size of just this crew.

Man cannot exist on science alone. the universities would also study the humanities as well. Free thinkers means no absolute faith in everything the govt/military does.

Andrew Kasantsev posted 11-11-98 02:48 AM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for Andrew Kasantsev  Click Here to Email Andrew Kasantsev     
>>She said to keep their sanity, she and her friends would just sit around and complain about how stupid the govt was.

Yeah, it is american way. Russians would tell funny story about that govmnt, stand up and go on...
About scientists riot - every scientist tend to think, that only (S)HE knows, how problem can be solved. Sometime it is ruin for project, where you need to have one good decision - you lose your time in endless search for better decision and arguments with one another...

SnowFire posted 11-11-98 03:49 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for SnowFire  Click Here to Email SnowFire     
Personally I don't see the UoP as actually having that much of a morale problem. Saratov hasn't shown himself to be that unliveable with...
DHE_X2 posted 11-11-98 04:00 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for DHE_X2  Click Here to Email DHE_X2     
sarcasm, gotta love it.
0leg posted 11-11-98 04:07 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for 0leg  Click Here to Email 0leg     
>>She said to keep their sanity, she and her friends would just sit around and
complain about how stupid the govt was.


I think you misunderstood her slightly. As Andrew mentioned, we did't really complained about gov., but rather sit together telling anectodes and laughing. What's a point to complain about the rain ? Just pick up your umbrella. Same is for government.
Cheers.

O242 2 posted 11-11-98 04:47 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for O242 2  Click Here to Email O242 2     
True, it was not just angry complaints.

Her story is as follows: She worked at some University (sorry don't remember which one). Some Government official showed up one day and told them all that they must grow corn in all of the local fields. There was only grain in those fields and for good reason too. The ground was mostly frozen. The top soil was about 1-2 inches at best. Corn does not grow in ground so shallow. Well it does but the crop is horrible, nothing left over to sell at the market. But this stupid official, who knew nothing about farming, insisted that corn was what must be grown. So my co-worker and her friends and university professors just sat around and told jokes about how stupid the government was while eating popcorn.

You are right, it was not really complaining about the govt more like laughing at the govt.

outlyr242 the rebirth posted 11-11-98 04:50 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for outlyr242 the rebirth  Click Here to Email outlyr242 the rebirth     
don;t be fooled by my username. I have two and keep forgetting to change it when i post.

0Leg, is the first character to your name a Zero or the letter "O". It looks like a zero.

0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0O0

0leg posted 11-30-98 06:28 PM ET     Click Here to See the Profile for 0leg  Click Here to Email 0leg     
Well, it should be "O" of course. But it is "0" since I made a mistake in my e-mail address when I registered. Thus the user name "Oleg" has been assigned to nonexistent e-mail address and I did't receive my password. When I tried to register again, computer did not let me use the name Oleg since it gas been already taken .
As a result I became 0leg

Thread ClosedTo close this thread, click here (moderator or admin only).

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Alpha Centauri Home

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.18
© Madrona Park, Inc., 1998.